RIGHT WHALE NEWS
The Newsletter of the Southeastern United States Implementation
Team for the Recovery of the Northern Right Whale and the Northeast
Implementation Team
Volume 8 Number 4 November 2001
Breakaway Gillnet Float
Wins Top Eubalaena Award
Competition Rewards Innovative Ways to Prevent Entanglement
A new design for breakaway gillnet floats has received the
Canadian Whale Institute's Eubalaena Award for 2001. Eric
deDoes of Plante's Lobster Escape Vents, Inc., in Somerville, Maine,
received a cash prize of $10,000 for the design.
Honorable Mention, with a cash prize of $2,500, was awarded to
José Rivera, Ed and Shari Wyman, and Andre and Robin Labonte
for their trap line storage devices to prevent whale entanglements.
The Visionary Award, also with a cash prize of $2,500, went to Dianne
Allen for her degradable polymer fishing line.
The Canadian Whale Institute established the Eubalaena
Award Competition to encourage the discovery of new ways to prevent
entanglements of right whales in fishing gear. This year's awards
were announced by Sarah Haney at the annual meeting of the North
Atlantic Right Whale Consortium, and the cash prizes were presented
on behalf of the Canadian Whale Institute and the New England
Aquarium.
The new design for breakaway gillnet floats resembles gillnet
floats currently in use. The outside football shape is made up of two
halves that are fastened together by screws. Internally, there are
two barbed clips that grasp each end of the float line. The clips
come in different sizes to accommodate rope of different sizes and
breaking strength. The line inside the float is then cut in two. When
a whale encounters the float, one end of the float will pull free,
reducing the risk of entanglement.
The winning trap-line storage devices to prevent whale
entanglements, one for shallow water and one for deep water, keep
rope coiled at the bottom until the end of the trap fishing period. A
galvanic time release corrodes at a pre-selected and predictable
rate, releasing the float to rise to the surface for recovery. These
devices seek to reduce the time that a vertical trap line is in the
water column, thus reducing the exposure to right whales, as well as
to other species of marine mammals and sea turtles.
Dianne Allen, recipient of the Visionary Award, employed a
chemical approach for her degradable polymer fishing line, in which
chemicals would be added to the mix during manufacturing. Using this
approach, a fishing net retains its original mechanical properties
for a specified and controllable period, followed by rapid
degradation under certain conditions, at which point the net would
break free and no longer be able to entangle a whale. The degradation
can be accelerated with several different chemicals and light. More
research on this concept is needed, but the approach looks
promising.
The other two finalists in the competition were Becky Woodward,
who designed a net gun that remotely deploys a tail harness (a lasso)
during the disentanglement process; and David Silvia, for a
spring-loaded fly-away knife to cut entangled line, with a blunt
version that can grab entangling line.
A total of 21 ideas were submitted in this year's competition by
18 people from all over the world. The jury looked especially for
devices that were practical, could be implemented quickly, and could
make a difference in the survival of right whales. They also wanted
to promote creative thinking and "outside the box" ideas. In the
first round of the competition last July, five finalists were chosen
and given funding to further develop their ideas. The finalists
demonstrated their devices in October at the North Atlantic Right
Whale Consortium meeting, where the winners were chosen and
announced.
For more information about the winning ideas, contact: Eric deDoes
(breakaway gillnet floats), 207-549-7204 or plantes@ctel.net;
José Rivera (trap line storage devices), 787-831-3426 or
jarivera@msn.com; Dianne Allen
(degradable polymer fishing line), 818-788-9471.
- Right Whale Numbers Offer Some
Hope
- But Research Continues to Suggest Long-term
Decline
The New England Aquarium's North Atlantic Right Whale
Catalog currently lists 410 North Atlantic right whales. According to
Phil Hamilton, 15 of these are known to be dead, and 95 are presumed
to be dead. (If a right whale has not been seen for six years, it is
presumed dead.) Thus, 300 animals are believed to be alive.
-
- Thirty-one calves were born during the 2000-2001 calving
season. Thirty of these were observed off the Georgia/Florida
coast; the 31st calf was not spotted until it reached northern
waters. This number is the highest count since
photo-identification efforts started in 1980.
-
- This also has been a record high year for deaths. Seven right
whales died (or can reasonably be assumed to have died) this year.
Four were calves; three were adults. Two of the calves were killed
as a result of ship collisions, one off Assateague, Virginia, and
the other off Long Island, New York. One of the adults (Churchill,
#1102) was seriously entangled; its satellite tag stopped
transmitting on September 16. This international media celebrity
probably died offshore in deep water; its body has not been
recovered. Another adult (#1114, a female) was satellite- tagged
in the Bay of Fundy this summer and tracked to waters off the
southeast coast of Nova Scotia. The last contact with the animal
occurred on September 2 when the transmitter recorded 27.5 hours
without a dive. Dr. Bruce Mate concludes that a catastrophic event
occurred at about that time, killing the whale. The proximity of
the whale's last known location to the major shipping lanes to and
from Europe provides circumstantial evidence as to the cause of
death, but unless the carcass can be recovered, the cause will
remain unknown. A third adult (#1238, a male) was reported dead
floating off the Magdelene Islands in the Gulf of the St.
Lawrence, Quebec, Canada, on October 25. The whale was entangled
in green polypropylene line. The cause of death has not been
determined yet, but a necropsy is planned.
-
- Last year, Dr. Stormy Mayo of the Center for Coastal Studies
successfully predicted last season's increase in calves, based on
an increase in food supply, especially in Cape Cod Bay. Dr. Mayo
now observes that based on the food resource alone, the 2001-2002
calving season should be even better than the last. However, he
notes that population demography suggests there are fewer "waiting
mothers" this coming season, so calf production should be high but
not record-setting.
-
- The long-term prognosis is not so bright. Masami Fujiwara and
Hal Caswell of the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution report
that their recent studies confirm earlier findings (1999) that
under current conditions, the population is doomed to extinction.
The declining survivability of mothers is primarily responsible
for the overall downward trend for the species. According to Phil
Hamilton, the calving interval continues to increase. The mean is
now 6.2 years (it was 3.67 years for the period between 1980 and
1992, and 5.8 years for 1990&endash;1998).
-
SAMs, DAMs and Gear
Limits:
- NMFS Proposes to Amend the Atlantic Large Whale
Take Reduction Plan
-
- The National Marine Fisheries Service has proposed three new
regulations to amend the Atlantic Large Whale Take Reduction Plan
(TRP) and further reduce the risk of entanglement of right whales.
The first, issued on October 1 as a proposed rule (Federal
Register 66 (190): 49896 &endash; 49908), addresses modifications
to gillnet and lobster fishing gear in the northeast, Mid-Atlantic
and southeast. The second, issued on October 2 as a proposed rule
(FR 66 (191): 50160 &endash; 50163), seeks to create dynamic
management areas (DAM). The third, issued a day later as an
advance notice of proposed rulemaking (FR 66 (192): 50390 &endash;
50394), would create a seasonal area management system (SAM).
-
- As a result of pressure from Federal Judge Woodlock, who in a
recent court hearing accused NMFS of "a mañana approach to
rulemaking," the agency is expected to issue a new proposed rule
for a seasonal area management system by November 23. Final rules
on all three regulations are due by December 30. The public
comment periods for all three of the rules proposed in October
have already expired. The comment period for the proposed SAM rule
has not been announced but is expected to be very brief.
-
- The draft rules can be accessed through the NMFS Northeast
Regional Office TRP web site: www.nero.nmfs.gov/whatetrp/
- Implementation Teams Respond to
Draft
- Ship Strike
Recommendations
-
- At its September 24&endash;25 meeting, the Southeast U.S.
Right Whale Recovery Plan Implementation Team (SEIT) developed a
response to proposals to require the re-routing of ships around
whales, restrict speed and mandate shipping lanes in right whale
habitat (see Right Whale News 8(3):12 for background). The
SEIT outlined its response in a letter to Dr. William T. Hogarth,
director of the National Marine Fisheries Service. The Northeast
Implementation Team met on October 24 to review the proposals, and
a letter from team chair Tom French is being developed.
-
- The SEIT letter, signed by chair Barb Zoodsma, reads as
follows:
-
- Dear Dr. Hogarth:
-
- Enclosed please find a report entitled Recommended Measures
to Reduce Ship Strikes of North Atlantic Right Whales. The
report, prepared by Bruce Russell with contributions from Amy
Knowlton and numerous others, was submitted to the Southeast U.S.
Right Whale Recovery Plan Implementation Team (SEIT) for
consideration and comment. The purpose of this letter is to convey
our comments to the NMFS regarding the report and Southeast
U.S.-related recommendations contained therein.
-
- The SEIT discussed the subject report at our 24-25 September
meeting conducted in Fernandina Beach, Florida. The Team
unanimously agreed that the process used in generating the report
was very inclusive and offered our constituents and us numerous
opportunities to provide input. We commend Bruce Russell, Amy
Knowlton, Barb Zoodsma and others specifically mentioned in the
report for their hard work in collecting available information,
listening to concerns, and attempting to consolidate various
issues while formulating the recommendations contained within the
report.
-
- We discussed the report's four recommended vessel-operating
restrictions that will affect Southeast U.S. ports. These
recommendations include:
-
- 1. Establish seasonal management areas at major port entrances
and approaches from Block Island, RI, south to and including
Savannah, GA.
2. Establish mandatory or designated recommended routes for the
ports of Brunswick, GA; Jacksonville, FL; and Fernandina Beach,
FL.
3. Establish a seasonal 10-knot speed restriction for vessels
calling at the ports of Brunswick, GA; Jacksonville, FL; and
Fernandina Beach, FL.
4. Require
that each vessel, prior to entering critical
habitat or dynamic or seasonal management area, check steering,
ensure engines are ready for maneuvering, and post trained lookouts
(not necessarily additional lookouts).
-
- The SEIT unanimously supported the prudent seamanship
recommendation (item number 4 above). Additionally, we generally
agreed with the report that numbers 1-3 are reasonable approaches
to minimizing collisions between whales and ships. The SEIT also
concurred with the report in that additional research needs to be
completed prior to settling upon the optimal management scheme for
the Southeast U.S (SEUS). For instance, Team members were
concerned about minimizing economic impacts of proposed
regulations on SEUS ports while implementing the management scheme
with the highest probability of reducing threats to whales.
Therefore, the SEIT unanimously recommends these options for
vessel operating restrictions be further considered after the
following studies are conducted or sufficient information exists
regarding risk reduction for each of the various recommendations.
Specifically, we are interested in the following:
- Model the economic impact of routes: from extreme routing
measures (e.g., one route per port entrance), to limited routing
measures (e.g., elimination of one route per port entrance), and
seasonal versus year-round/permanent routing changes. This model
should be similar to the model constructed to analyze economic
impacts of speed restrictions.
- Model the economic impacts of seasonal and/or year-round 10
knot speed restriction versus a 13 knot speed restriction.
- Members that represent port authorities are concerned that
speed or routing restrictions will result in the elimination of
port calls to their facilities. Speed and/or routing restrictions
may also cause delays. These members would like to see a model
that reflects the economic impact if ships are delayed or if ships
refrain from calling on their ports and opt to call on ports with
fewer restrictions (e.g., from Jacksonville to Charleston).
- What is the measurable reduction in risk that will result from
speed restrictions or routing measures?
- Conduct a risk assessment to determine what will result in the
greatest reduction of threats to whales, while minimizing economic
impacts to ports. We believe this work should be conducted
following the sightings-per-unit-effort analysis for 1992/1993 to
2000/2001 Southeast U.S. right whale aerial survey data that is
currently underway by the Florida Marine Research Institute.
- Conduct a Port Access Route study.
-
- The SEIT recognizes the urgent need to enhance right whale
protection efforts. Therefore, we propose that, while the above
studies are completed in preparation of well-founded, long-term
management plans, efforts continue between NMFS and the SEIT
to:
-
- 1. Develop and implement voluntary measures such as those
adopted by the Crowley Liner Service and presented to the SEIT by
Mike Getchell, Jacksonville Marine Transportation Exchange;
-
- 2. Enhance the development and distribution of educational
materials;
-
- 3. Improve Mandatory Ship Reporting compliance.
High Speed Vessels and Right
Whales
The Cat is a 300-foot long, high-speed ferry that operates
between Bar Harbor, Maine, and Yarmouth, Nova Scotia, cruising at a
speed of 40 knots. Since its inaugural season in 1998, Bay Ferries,
Ltd., operators of The Cat, have retained the services of a biologist
to monitor the presence of whales along her route. For the first
three years of operation, very few right whales were seen. In 2001,
however, an estimated 40 to 60 right whales took up residence along a
portion of the ferry's route. Most of them were observed in the
eastern end of the run in Canadian waters. Once right whales had been
sighted, the captain attempted to avoid the areas where whales had
been seen by re-routing either to the north or south. Other measures
were taken, including posting additional watches, placing the crew on
high alert and switching from auto-pilot to manual steering.
-
- Amy Knowlton of the New England Aquarium reports that even
with the re-routing, right whales remained concentrated along the
new route. She noted that The Cat was not observed to slow down in
the presence of right whales.
-
- It appears that neither Canada nor the United States has
figured out how to regulate high-speed vessel operations to reduce
the threat to right whales. The draft Updated Recovery Plan barely
touches on the topic and then only under whale watching.
-
-
- Federal Funding for Right Whales
Awaits Final Action
-
- Speculating on the next fiscal year's budget for right whales
is always risky, since final numbers are generally not known until
the House and Senate agree on the appropriation for the Department
of Commerce. The tragic events of September 11 and their aftermath
make speculation on the FY 2002 budget even more difficult than
normal. Before September 11, the appropriations committees of both
houses appeared to be reaching agreement on a $7 million package
for right whales. Most of the funds would go to the National
Marine Fisheries Service. Some might go to the U.S. Coast Guard
and some might go to the Northeast Consortium (see Right Whale
News 8(1):2 for background). In the meantime, the NMFS will
operate under a continuing resolution until final appropriations
are determined.
-
-
- Right Whale Recovery Act Legislation
Proposed
-
- Senator John Kerry (D&endash;MA) has introduced the "North
Atlantic Right Whale Recovery Act of 2001" to coordinate and
expand U.S. and international programs for the conservation and
protection of North Atlantic right whales. A similar measure has
been introduced in the House by Representative William Delahunt
(D&endash;MA). The sections of the Senate version are: (1) short
title; (2) findings; (3) North Atlantic right whale recovery
program; (4) federal-state cooperation; (5) North Atlantic right
whale priority action program; (6) reducing ship strikes; (7)
North Atlantic right whale research grant program; (8) interagency
coordination and cost-sharing; (9) international action and
coordination; (10) report to Congress; and (11) authorization of
appropriations.
-
- Basically, the bill institutionalizes the current right whale
recovery program. It serves to elevate issues between the
Departments of Commerce, State, Defense and Transportation to the
secretarial level. It also provides higher visibility to the
program, which should be helpful in the appropriations process. As
for funding, the bill authorizes an increase of appropriations to
total $8 million for fiscal year 2002. The authorizations for FY
2003 and 2004 would increase to $10 million. Even if passed in its
present form, the funds will still need to be appropriated as part
of the budget process.
-
- A hearing on the bill was scheduled for September but was
postponed indefinitely after September 11.
People and Programs: Several Changes
Announced
There are three teams implementing recovery plans for the North
Atlantic right whale in the western North Atlantic. Two of them
recently have changed their names and recruited new leadership. In
the southeast, the name is now the Southeast U.S. Right Whale
Recovery Plan Implementation Team. It is chaired by Barb Zoodsma of
the Georgia Department of Natural Resources (tel. 912-264-7218;
e-mail: Barb_Zoodsma@mail.dnr.state.ga.us).
While the vice chair position is currently vacant, the heir apparent
is Jameson Smith, who replaced Cyndi Thomas at the Florida Marine
Research Institute. (Cyndi now works for The Ocean Conservancy.) The
Canadian team is now the Canadian North Atlantic Right Whale
Implementation Team. Its co-chairs are Jerry Conway of the Department
of Fisheries and Oceans (902-426-6947; conwayj@mar.dfo-mpo.gc.ca)
and Dr. Moe Brown of the Canadian Whale Institute and the Center for
Coastal Studies (508-487-3623; Mbrown@coastalstudies.org).
The northeast team remains the Northeast Implementation Team; its
chair is Dr. Tom French of the Massachusetts Division of Fish and
Wildlife (508-792-7270; tom.french@state.ma.us)
. The vice chair is Tom Fetherston of the U.S. Navy (401-832-5857;
fetherstontn@AM.Npt.NUWC.Navy.mil).
A number of changes in personnel also have occurred recently in
the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), including positions
with direct responsibilities for right whales. Dr. William Hogarth
has been named director of the NMFS. Dr. Hogarth has worked for the
agency for 16 years and has served in a number of roles, including
Acting Assistant Administrator for Fisheries and Southeast Regional
Administrator. In the Northeast Regional Office, Mary Colligan is
Chief of the Protected Resources Division. Dave Gouveia is the Marine
Mammal Coordinator. Greg LaMontagne, formerly the Acting Large Whale
Take Reduction Plan Coordinator, has new duties within NMFS. Diane
Borggaard is the new Large Whale Take Reduction Plan Coordinator. In
the Southeast Regional Office, Georgia Cranmore is the new Chief of
the Protected Resources Division. Dr. Kathy Wang, the marine mammal
team leader, has a new assistant: fisheries biologist Katie Moore.
Don Lewis is the new right whale/shipping industry liaison for the
Southeast Regional Office.
The State of Maine has a new Large Whale Take Reduction Plan
coordinator: Laura Ludwig. She will serve as a liaison with Maine
fishermen, coastal communities, the state's seven Lobster Zone
Management Councils and the Department of Marine Resources. She also
will be responsible for developing and implementing a state sighting
and surveillance program, an education and outreach program for
fishermen and coastal communities, and an entanglement response plan.
She can be reached at 207-633-9556.
The North Atlantic Right Whale Consortium has new officers and
board members. Amy Knowlton of the New England Aquarium will chair
the Consortium for the next three years. Dr. Michael Moore of the
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution is vice chair. Marilyn Marx of
the New England Aquarium continues as secretary, and Deb Tobin of
East Coast Ecosystems continues as public information officer.
Joining the board are Dr. Bruce Mate (Oregon State University) and
Phil Hamilton (New England Aquarium). Dr. Robert Kenney (University
of Rhode Island) was re-elected to the board. Continuing board
members are Dr. Brad White, Dr. Moe Brown, Laurie Murison and Dr. Roz
Rolland. Outgoing chair Scott Kraus and board member Dr. Stormy Mayo
are retiring from the board.
Right Whale Consortium Launches New Educational Web
Site
- The North Atlantic Right Whale Consortium is establishing a
new web site for the dissemination of information on research,
conservation, whale rescue and other topics. Designed to reach the
general public, the site will also be used to promote
communication and to archive information on right whales. Focus
areas will include whale facts, events (e.g., sightings,
entanglements and calving), maps, projects (e.g., research and
rescue efforts), data on individual whales, and games. The site
includes a media gallery, with photographs, video and audio of
right whales. There also are detailed maps showing right whale
habitats in both the United States and Canada and locations of
right whales throughout the year. The site should be accessible in
December at: www.rightwhaleweb.org
-
- The web site was created and developed under the leadership of
the Consortium's public information officer, Deb Tobin of East
Coast Ecosystems, and Nick Rutter of Accesstec, Inc. Caris Spatial
Fusion provided the mapping products. (For details on the web site
setup, contact Nick Rutter at 506-452-9780 or nickr@accesstec.ca)
The Federal Government of Canada provided financial support
through Environment Canada's Habitat Stewardship Program.
-
Right Whale Catalog Goes
Electronic
- With more than 23,000 records and 10,000 new ones to add each
year, the New England Aquarium has decided to shift from a paper
catalog to a new electronic catalog for its records of North
Atlantic right whales. The e-catalog has just been released on
compact disk. For each of the catalog's 411 right whales, there
are six of the best photographic images and a drawn composite. One
of the catalog's most useful features will be its searchability. A
researcher can, for example, find an individual whale based on
photographs of only one side of the head of the animal. The search
feature also allows users to track such things as scarification
rates. The catalog is available for $20.00 from the Aquarium.
Contact Stephanie Martin for details (617-973-0211; or: smartin@neaq.org).
The Aquarium plans to update the electronic catalog every two to
three years.
Papers Presented at Annual Consortium
Meeting
The North Atlantic Right Whale Consortium held its annual meeting
at the New England Aquarium October 25&endash;26. More than 142
people attended, making it the largest Consortium meeting ever. The
agenda included a business meeting, presentations of scientific
papers, reports on shipping and fishing conflicts, discussions of the
development of a strategy for public relations, and permitting for
right whales. The five finalists for the Eubalaena awards
demonstrated their disentanglement devices, and the Eubalaena
awards were presented.
A list of presented papers follows, with only senior authors
identified. An asterisk (*) following the title indicates that an
abstract is available. The collection of abstracts may be purchased
for $5 from the Consortium secretary, Marilyn Marx
(mmarx@neaq.org).
Current Population Status Reports
- The North Atlantic Right Whale Catalog: An update,* P.
Hamilton
- A proposed monitoring protocol for the North Atlantic right
whale population,* H. Caswell et al.
-
- Demography of the North Atlantic right whale,* M. Fujiwara et
al.
- Scarification analysis of North Atlantic right whales:
Monitoring rates of entanglement interaction,* A. Knowlton et
al.
-
- East Coast Survey Summaries,* T. Cole and C. Slay
-
- Biology
- Genetic analysis of whale bones from a 16th Century Basque
whaling station,* T. Frasier et al.
Studying North Atlantic right whale reproduction using fecal
steroid hormones: An update,* R. Rolland et al.
A new technique for visually assessing right whale body
condition,* H. Pettis et al.
Molecular analysis of stress activated proteins and genes in
cetaceans: A new methodology for monitoring environmental stress
impact in right whales,* S. Southern et al. (presented by P.
Clapham)
-
- Blubber thickness and reproductive success in right whales,*
C. Miller et al.
-
- Shipping Issues
- Research, studies and projects in support of recommended
measures to reduce ship strikes of North Atlantic right whales,*
B. Russell
-
- GIS modeling of right whale and ship traffic distributions:
Decision support for right whale conservation,* L. Ward et
al.
-
- The occurrence of North Atlantic right whales along the route
of The Cat during the summer of 2001,* S. Dufault (presented by A.
Knowlton)
Progress report on measures to reduce potential for ship
collisions in
- Canadian waters: M. Brown
Acoustics
- Passive acoustic detection and tracking of right whales in
Cape Cod Bay and the Great South Channel: Results and implications
for future survey efforts,* C. Clark et al.
-
- Assessing ship strike risk factors, an update on the DTAG
project,*
- D. Nowacek et al.
-
- Playbacks of surface active group calls to North Atlantic
right whales (Eubalaena glacialis),* S. Parks
Right whale call characterization to assist passive acoustic
detection,*J. Matthews
Right whale acoustics: Practical applications in conservation,*
D. Gillespie et al.
Fishing Conflicts with Right Whales
- Right whale entanglements and disentanglements, 2001,* D.
Morin
Churchill: procedures and lessons, C. Good
Take Reduction Team update, G. LaMontagne
Canadian update, J. Conway
Humane Society of the U.S. versus NMFS: Update, S. Young
Field trials of the whale-free buoy, C. Goudey
Habitat Studies
- Right whale nighttime feeding behavior in the lower Bay of
Fundy: Inferences from a study of Calanus finmarchicus diel
vertical migration,* M. Baumgartner et al.
-
- Climate, copepods, and calves: Linking right whale
reproduction to physical and biological conditions in the NW
Atlantic,* A. Pershing et al.
A survey of historic right whale habitat in the North Atlantic
Ocean Basin,* M. Moore
- Statistical associations between North Atlantic right whale
movements and oceanographic and physical parameters,* S. Kraus et
al.
-
- GIS presentation of survey tracks, right whale sightings and
right whale movements: 1978-2000,* A. Knowlton et al.
New Approaches and Information on Ongoing
Studies
- Right Whale E-Catalog, S. Martin
Consortium Website, N. Rutter
Can tagging right whales aid in their conservation and
recovery?* B. Mate
-
- Stable isotopes, S. Wetmore (presented by P. Clapham)
Photogrammetry study, D. Potter
-
- AWARE sonar project, D. Potter
-
- National Whale Conservation Fund status, M. Pico
Scientific Research Permits: The Conversation
Continues
- On Thursday evening, October 25, Ms. Ruth Johnson and Dr.
Tammy Adams made a brief presentation to the participants at the
Right Whale Consortium meeting in Boston on current status and
procedures related to scientific research permits. A lively
discussion followed. One audience member noted that the
conversation on this topic extended back some 15 years.
-
- Specific to the interests of right whale investigators, there
appear to be three levels or components: (1) the language in the
statute - the Endangered Species Act, (2) the language in the
regulations - the 500-yard approach rule, and (3) the language put
forward as a result of what is described as legal interpretation.
The rub seems to stem principally from the legal interpretation
area. Fairly stated, there are many dimensions to this topic, and,
the National Marine Fisheries Service is in a situation of
responding to external events and pressures. For those wishing to
participate in and/or educate themselves on this topic, the
Permits Division website is recommended: www.nmfs.noaa.gov/prot_res/overview/permits.html.
There will also be a workshop entitled " Obtaining a Marine Mammal
Scientific Research and Enhancement Permit," on December 1, at the
14th Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals in
Vancouver, Canada. Lastly, the permit office is said to be
planning a meeting on this topic for early in 2002, dates and
information to be forthcoming.
- Commentary:
- There's gotta be a better
way!
-
- At the Right Whale Consortium meeting in Boston on October 26,
we were provided with an update and description of the right-whale
related legal actions involving the National Marine Fisheries
Service (NMFS). The prolonged schedule of arguments, court dates,
and description of judges' opinions causes us to wonder. NMFS,
rightly and/or wrongly, comes under criticism. Responding to
continuing episodes of legal actions, the agency burrows deeper,
hires additional staff, and generates additional paperwork,
meetings, and regulations - often on a short-fuse timeframe.
-
- Recurring questions include: What is the net cost/benefit
ratio of these activities? Are expenditures of limited time and
resources being best applied to protection and conservation of
right whales? Is this the best we can do? There's gotta be a
better way!
Jim Hain
- Scientific Literature and
Reports
- Anderson, P. K. 2001. Marine mammals in the next one hundred
years: Twilight for a Pleistocene megafauna? Journal of Mammalogy
82 (3): 623&endash;629.
-
- Clapham, P. J. and R. L. Brownell, Jr. 1999. Vulnerability of
migratory baleen whales to ecosystem degradation. Pp. 97-106 in
UNEP/CMS (ed.), Proceedings of the Symposium on Animal Migration.
Gland, Switzerland. 13 April 1997. CMS Technical Series
Publication No. 2, Bonn/The Hague.
-
- DeMaster, D. P., C. W. Fowler, S. L. Perry and M. F. Richlen.
2001. Predation and competition: The impact of fisheries on
marine-mammal populations over the next one hundred years. Journal
of Mammalogy 82 (3): 641&endash;651.
-
- Harwood, J. 2001. Marine mammals and their environment in the
twenty-first century. Journal of Mammalogy 82 (3):
630&endash;640.
-
- Gillespie, D. and R. Leaper. 2001. Report of the workshop on
right whale acoustics: Practical applications in conservation.
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, March 8&endash;9, 2001.
Convened by the International Fund for Animal Welfare. Pp. iii and
23.
-
- Nowacek, D. P., M. P. Johnson, P. L.Tyack, K. A. Shorter, W.
A. McLellan and D. A. Pabst. 2001. Buoyant balaenids: The ups and
downs of buoyancy in right whales. Proceedings of the Royal
Society of London Series B &endash; Biological Sciences 268(1478):
1811-1816.
-
- Weisbrod, W, D. Shea, G. Leblanc, M. Moore and J. J. Stegeman.
2000. Organochlorine bioaccumulation and risk for whales in a
northwest Atlantic food web. Marine Environmental Research
50(1-5): 440-441.
Calendar of Events
- January 11, 2002: Deadline for submitting National Whale
Conservation Fund pre-proposals to the National Fish and Wildlife
Foundation. (Full proposals will be by invitation.) For guidelines
and additional information, contact Michelle Pico at 202-857-0166
or pico@nfwf.org
-
- February 1: Copy deadline for the next issue of Right Whale
News. See page 14 for details.
-
- February 6: Next meeting of the Northeast Implementation Team.
Location to be determined. For further information, contact Dr.
Sal Testaverde at 978-281-9368 or Salvatore.Testaverde@noaa.gov
-
- February 8: Deadline for applications for funding from the Massachusetts Environmental Trust's Biodiversity Program for fiscal year 2003. For guidelines, contact MET at 617-727-0249 or visit their web site at: www.MassEnvironmentalTrust.org
-
- March 19-21: Tentative dates for the next meeting of the
Canadian North Atlantic Right Whale Implementation Team, St.
Andrews, New Brunswick. Agenda topics include the coordination of
right whale research in the Bay of Fundy, permitting and future
recovery efforts. For further information, contact team co-chair
Jerry Conway at 902-426-6947 or conwayj@mar.dfo-mpo.gc.ca
-
- April 4-7: Florida Marine Mammal Health Conference, University
of Florida Hotel and Conference Center, Gainesville, Florida. The
conference seeks to promote the health and well-being of the four
principal species of marine mammals found in Florida waters:
manatees, bottlenose dolphins, pygmy sperm whales and North
Atlantic right whales. For further information, contact Dr. Iske
L. Vandevelde Larkin at 352-392-4700, ext. 3866 or e-mail:
Larkin@mail.vetmed.ufl.edu
-
- May 9&endash;10: Next meeting of the Southeast U.S. Right
Whale Recovery Plan Implementation Team. Location to be
determined. For further information, contact team chair Barb
Zoodsma at 912-264-7218 or Barb_Zoodsma@mail.dnr.state.ga.us
-
- October 17&endash;18: Fall meeting of the Southeast U.S. Right
Whale Recovery Plan Implementation Team. Location to be
determined. For further information, contact team chair Barb
Zoodsma at 912-264-7218 or Barb_Zoodsma@mail.dnr.state.ga.us
-
- October 29&endash;30: Annual meeting of the North Atlantic
Right Whale Consortium. Location to be determined. For further
information, contact Marilyn Marx at: mmarx@neaq.org
Right Whale News
- Right Whale News is the newsletter of the Southeastern
U.S. Right Whale Recovery Plan Implementation Team and the
Northeast Implementation Team. The editor is Hans Neuhauser. The
editorial board consists of Bill Brooks, Moe Brown, Phil Clapham,
Jerry Conway, Jim Hain, Scott Kraus, Mike Payne, Sigrid Sanders
and Jerry Wallmeyer.
-
- The Gray's Reef National Marine Sanctuary, the Massachusetts
Environmental Trust, the Southeast Regional Office of NOAA
Fisheries, the Northeast Implementation Team and the Savannah
Presbytery's M. K. Pentecost Ecology Trust Fund (www.savannahpresbytery.org)
have underwritten the costs of Right Whale News. Thanks to
their support, Right Whale News is published quarterly and
is distributed free of charge.
-
- The current issue of Right Whale News is now available
on line at a web site maintained by the Georgia Environmental
Policy Institute: www.GEPInstitute.com
-
- An index of the first five years of Right Whale News
(1994-1998) is available along with current and back issues on
the Internet, thanks to Alex Score and Marcy Lee of the Gray's
Reef National Marine Sanctuary. The web site address is: http://www.graysreef.nos.noaa.gov/rightwhalenews.html
-
- To subscribe to Right Whale News or to submit news,
articles or commentary for publication, contact the editor, Hans
Neuhauser, at the Georgia Environmental Policy Institute, 380
Meigs Street, Athens, GA 30601, USA. Telephone 706-546-7507. Fax
706-613-7775. E-mail: gepi@ix.netcom.com
Back to top page